Your Local 

Real Estate Expert

Find your dream home with our powerful property search tool!

Realtor

Jen Fenster

Send a message
Watch My Story
Head Shot June 2025(1)

A little bit about me...

Jen is a proud UW–Madison alum, a CPA of 20 years, and a dedicated real estate professional serving Dane County. With a strong foundation in finance and a natural eye for design, Jen blends analytical skill with creative insight to help clients buy, sell, and invest with confidence. Her ability to see potential in any property, not just in structure, but in style and functionality truly sets her apart. Jen has even assisted clients with furnishing and visioning their spaces, ensuring they feel truly at home.

A relationship-driven agent, Jen’s commitment to her clients extends far beyond the closing table. She believes that buying or selling a home is one of life’s most meaningful milestones, and she considers it a privilege to be part of that journey. Her clients quickly become friends, a testament to her genuine care, integrity, and dedication.

At home, Jen has been married to her husband, Peter, for almost 20 years, and together they have three children: Ethan (16), Emerson (14), and Greyson (10), as well as a bonus son through their role as a billet family for hockey. Hockey is a big part of their lives, so much so that they build a backyard rink each winter. The family also loves cheering on all Wisconsin sports.

Rooted in community, family, and service, Jen brings warmth, professionalism, and exceptional skill to every client she serves.

Find it all

Closer to home

In the Words of my Clients

Success Stories

"Charlie and Jen did a wonderful job and made selling my condo seamless! Charlie helped me buy my condo back in 2021, so when it was time to sell, I knew I could reach back out to him. My schedule during this time was pretty busy with finishing school
"Worked with Jen Fenster throughout my buying process and let me tell you she’s been a wonderful part of the whole experience. I cannot thank Jen and the Wills Agency for making my first buying experience a joyful and exciting one!"
"It’s hard to capture in words how grateful we are to the Wills Agency! They made our huge transition of selling our home of 14 years and buying a brand new home feel so smooth and quite fun! Charlie and Jen treated us with genuine care and respect,
"We have utilized Charlie and his team a few times and would highly recommend their expertise and services. I live out-of-state and the sales of our properties required a lot of communication and access to his network of professionals. They knocked it

Is it a good time to sell?

How Much is your home really worth?

Let me provide you with a personalized, in-person valuation report. You'll receive an accurate, detailed analysis of your property's value, including insights into market trends and potential opportunities for improvement.

Get your home value

Our

Exclusive Listings

View all

Ready to take

The next step?

Not sure if now's the right time to buy or sell? Need a reliable contractor? I would love to get to know more about you and your needs!